skip to main content
We may earn money when you click our links.

Beyond Rudolph: 10 Strange Christmas Specials You Need To See

Collage of scenes with the headline 'Strange Christmas Specials.'

We all know that when it comes to Christmas, seeing is not believing. But sometimes, you have to watch something to believe that a network executive actually greenlit it.

If you’re tired of the usual sentimental holiday mush and looking for something unhinged, you’ve come to the right place. I’ve dug deep into the TV archives to find 10 strange Christmas specials that trade cozy fireplaces for psychedelic animation, awkward celebrity cameos, and unsubtitled Wookiee drama.

From the intentional absurdity of Tim and Eric to the unintentional nightmare fuel of “Rapsittie Street Kids,” these aren’t the holiday specials you leave on while wrapping gifts. They’re the ones that make you stop and stare in disbelief. So put down the cocoa, pick up the remote, and let’s count down the weirdness.

10. “Matt Rogers: Have You Heard of Christmas?” (2022)

Christmas has been around for centuries, but apparently nobody has explained it properly. Enter Matt Rogers, who’s here to set the record straight and make his case as the holiday’s next pop prince. In this 2022 Showtime special, the “Las Culturistas” co-host takes the stage at Joe’s Pub in NYC for an evening of original holiday songs, big vocals, and even bigger self-confidence. Think an intimate Christmas concert with the ego dialed up to eleven.

Along the way, Rogers enlists Bowen Yang and comedians Josh Sharp and Aaron Jackson to play along with the absurd premise. It’s still probably the least bizarre special on this list, which is saying something. But anyone who goes this far for a fictional holiday pop career deserves some recognition.

I also highly recommend checking out Rogers’ “Have You Heard of Christmas?” album. The songs are genuinely catchy, and a few might even sneak into your regular holiday playlist. Just beware of the expletives.

9. “A Colbert Christmas: The Greatest Gift of All!” (2008)

Stephen Colbert’s Christmas special has all the ingredients of a classic celebrity variety show: famous guests, original songs, and a bear keeping the host trapped in a cabin. Colbert is supposed to perform in New York, but naturally, the show has to come to him instead. That’s the premise of this 2008 Comedy Central special, which turns a familiar holiday formula into one big self-aware joke.

Willie Nelson, Feist, John Legend, Toby Keith, and Jon Stewart all join in, with songs ranging from heartwarming to ridiculous. “A Colbert Christmas” is more conventional than some of the entries below, but a bear-induced holiday hostage situation is still a pretty good excuse for a musical.

8. “Blackadder’s Christmas Carol” (1988)

If you’re unfamiliar with “Blackadder,” the BBC sitcom was co-created by “Mr. Bean” star Rowan Atkinson and “Love Actually” screenwriter Richard Curtis. Its talented cast included Hugh Laurie and Stephen Fry, with Robbie Coltrane joining the Christmas special.

I know what you’re thinking: Not another “A Christmas Carol” adaptation. But this one turns the Dickens classic on its head. Atkinson plays the “nicest man in England,” a saintly figure constantly exploited by everyone around him. Then Coltrane’s Spirit of Christmas pays a visit, and Blackadder learns that being bad is way more fun.

7. “A Claymation Christmas Celebration” (1987)

I already covered this in our Claymation Christmas rundown, but it absolutely belongs here too. Why? Because watching anthropomorphic raisins sing holiday songs alongside bickering clay dinosaurs is the definition of weird.

Hosted by Rex and Herb, two prehistoric critics with surprisingly sophisticated vocabulary, this stop-motion special feels more off-kilter than the cozy Rankin/Bass classics. Between the California Raisins’ Motown-style “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer” and a conductor struggling to orchestrate sentient bells, the whole thing is a trip. It proves the late ’80s were a lawless wasteland of children’s entertainment.

6. “A Cosmic Christmas” (1977)

Before E.T. ever phoned home, Canadian animation studio Nelvana introduced three extraterrestrials with a much more seasonal mission: figuring out what Christmas is all about. In this 1977 special, the visitors look suspiciously like the Three Wise Men. But they look to a young boy named Peter and his pet goose, Lucy, to help them understand Christmas on Earth.

Things take a turn when a local bully steals Lucy, leading to a rescue on a frozen lake and an unexpected lesson in kindness. It’s a sweet story at heart, but the otherworldly animation makes the visitors feel like they’ve wandered in from a completely different movie. Only in the ’70s could an alien visitation and a missing goose count as wholesome holiday programming.

5. “He-Man & She-Ra: A Christmas Special” (1985)

Christmas on Eternia? Sure, why not? In this 1985 crossover, Orko accidentally transports two Earth children to He-Man and She-Ra’s home planet, where they worry about missing Christmas. Queen Marlena brings some holiday cheer to the palace, but Horde Prime sees the Christmas spirit as a threat and sends his villains after the kids.

The real surprise isn’t seeing a Christmas tree amid the sword-and-sorcery action. It’s watching Skeletor, of all people, develop a soft spot for the children he’s supposed to kidnap. He-Man and She-Ra still get their heroics, but the Lord of Destruction learning about goodwill is what really stretches the imagination.

4. “Pee-wee’s Playhouse Christmas Special” (1988)

For a certain generation, this is the holy grail of Christmas TV specials. But for everyone else, this chaotic variety hour might feel like a festive hallucination. I mean, where else do you get Cher screaming the secret word, Grace Jones singing after emerging from a shipping crate, and Oprah Winfrey making a cameo, all under one roof?

It’s a campy masterpiece that balances nostalgic kitsch with over-the-top ’80s energy. And if you haven’t seen k.d. lang perform “Jingle Bell Rock” in Pee-wee’s Playhouse, you haven’t truly experienced the holiday spirit.

3. “The Star Wars Holiday Special” (1978)

Few holiday specials are as infamous as this 1978 broadcast. Aired only once on CBS, “The Star Wars Holiday Special” attempts to merge the space opera of “Star Wars” with a traditional TV variety show. The plot follows Han Solo trying to get Chewbacca home for Life Day, with long stretches of Wookiees interacting without subtitles.

Then come Bea Arthur, Jefferson Starship, and members of the original “Star Wars” cast, all trapped in something that feels like an artifact from another galaxy. The full special has never received an official rerelease, but unofficial uploads of this Wookiee-sized fever dream have found their way onto YouTube. For a more legitimate taste of Life Day, you can stream its animated segment, “The Story of the Faithful Wookiee,” on Disney+.

2. “Tim and Eric Awesome Show, Great Job! Chrimbus Special” (2010)

Explaining “Tim and Eric Awesome Show, Great Job!” is impossible, and the same goes for its 2010 “Chrimbus Special.” No, that’s not a typo. Framed as a promotional DVD “for retailers only,” it’s 45 minutes of television at the height of its powers, featuring winter shrubbery, Pasta Bears, and the mythical Dee Vee.

You can stream the “Chrimbus Special” on Hulu, where it’s tucked away at the end of Season 5. It may be the only holiday special that makes Christmas look like the sensible alternative. But fair warning: “A Song for Dee Vee” may get stuck in your head and re-emerge when you least expect it.

1. “Rapsittie Street Kids: Believe in Santa” (2002)

Some Christmas specials are strange on purpose. This one looks like an unfinished animation test that somehow became the final product.

In 2002’s “Rapsittie Street Kids: Believe in Santa,” a boy named Ricky offers a classmate the teddy bear his late mother gave him, only for her to throw it away. It’s a fairly standard lesson about kindness buried under one of the most bewildering computer-animated productions I’ve ever seen.

Characters glide, grimace, and contort through scenes that feel like a glitchy early video game. And somehow, the voice cast includes Mark Hamill, Jodi Benson, and Paige O’Hara, which only makes it all the more surreal. If we’re ranking these by sheer “How did this get made?” energy, it takes the top spot.

More holiday fare to add to your watchlist

Collage of scenes from 'White Reindeer,' 'Kiss Kiss Bang Bang,' and 'Brazil' with the headline 'Underrated Christmas Movies.'

Skip the Standards: 13 Underrated Christmas Movies To Shake Up Your Holiday Watchlist

Nov 13, 2026

Tired of the same old classics? Discover 13 underrated Christmas movies, with vintage gems, anime, thrillers, dark comedies, and more to watch.

Best Christmas TV Episodes

8 Best Christmas TV Episodes

Nov 27, 2024

TV Christmas episodes are better than Christmas movies in at least one aspect: They’re shorter—do you have time to watch a two-hour film during the holiday season? Ho-ho-nope. Here are some great modern-classic TV Christmas episodes to squeeze in this yuletide season, including a couple that may spike your familial anxiety. (You’ve been warned.)

Claymation Christmas Movies text over an image of Shaun the Sheep.

10 Claymation Christmas Movies To Stream This Holiday Season

Nov 26, 2025

Claymation, an intricate form of animation created through stop-motion photography and manipulating clay figurines by hand, is forever linked to Christmas (all apologies to Gumby and Mr. Bill). Call us nostalgic—here are some of our holiday claymation favorites.

Don't miss an update

Stay updated on the latest products and services anytime anywhere.

Curious what TV and internet providers are in your area?