skip to main content
We may earn money when you click our links.

Only Murders in the Building Season 2 Episode 6 Preview

Whodunit on Only Murders in the Building this season? breaks down the odds.

Who among us hasn’t had a bad dinner party? In last week’s episode, Mabel hosted a fancy artist party for Alice (Cara Delevigne) that Oliver hijacked for a revealing game of Son of Sam. As for Charles, he reconnected with Jan (Amy Ryan), who helped him work through problems both personal and case-related.

For this week’s episode of Only Murders in the Building, let’s update the Only Murders Suspicion Power Rankings and see who’s worthy of a raised eyebrow. As always, we’re ranking characters from most to least suspicious by using two questions:

  1. Do we think they killed Bunny Folger?
  2. Did they have something to do with the murder?

Only Murders in the Building
“Hello, Darkness”

Only Murders In the Building (Hulu)

« Previous recap

Next recap » 

How can I watch Only Murders in the Building?

You can watch the first two seasons of Only Murders in the Building on Hulu. Check out our Hulu review to learn more about the streaming service.

View Hulu plans

1A. Teddy Dimas

Everyone in the Putnam family loves Dimas products, we guess?

The revelation that Teddy Dimas (Nathan Lane) might be the father of Oliver’s son keeps Teddy right at the top of our rankings for another week. If you’re looking to get revenge on the person who sent you and your son to prison, “I had an affair with your wife” is a hell of a card to have around.

A scene with Nathan Lane in an elevator in the Hulu show Only Murders in the Building.
Teddy Dimas (Nathan Lane) is potentially the father of Oliver’s son. Image courtesy Hulu.

1B. Alice Banks

Only two types of people are deranged enough to cause that much drama at a party: murder suspects and art scenesters. If she was lying about being the Son of Sam, was her whole spiel about lying about her background also a lie?

A scene with Cara Delevigne taking a phone call during the Hulu show Only Murders in the Building.
Alice Banks (Cara Delevigne) in Only Murders in the Building. Image courtesy Hulu.

2. Amy Schumer

Last week’s episode helped narrow down The Actual Murderer’s timeline. We know they met with Bunny at the Pickle Diner, grabbed a matchbook that ended up in the tunnel, and potentially made the phone call to Bunny earlier in the season.

We’ll admit this ranking is a distant number two versus our top suspects, but at this point in the season, Only Murders in the Building’s only lopped off a number of red herrings. In the absence of better suspects, the show hasn’t acquitted Amy Schumer just yet.

3. Marv

Podcast superfan Marv (Daniel Oreskes) offhandedly mentions he knows about the Arconia’s secret tunnels thanks to his job doing mold removal. We’d call this theory a stretch, but we’ll keep it on the board for now.

Others receiving suspicious votes

  • Jan (wouldn’t go back to the well twice, but she is pretty good at murdering)
  • Theo Dimas (probably wasn’t at the Pickle Diner, but still Teddy-adjacent)
  • Jared, Nina Lin’s baby daddy (she didn’t do the murder, but maybe he’s going rogue)

Don't miss an update

Stay updated on the latest products and services anytime anywhere.