Which is Better: Surround Sound or Soundbars?
Pros and Cons
Get surround sound for a home theater with mind-blowing sound.
Sure, surround sound systems can be bulky and difficult to set up, but if you want an incredible home theater, this isn’t the place to cut corners. Just like it says in the name, the sounds of your favorite shows and movies will surround and immerse you, transporting you to Star Wars’s Tatooine or Game of Thrones’s Westeros.
Get a soundbar for a sleek-looking improvement on your TV’s default sound.
If you find the phrase “audiophile” a little pompous but still want something better than your TV’s built-in speakers, a soundbar is the right choice for you. Soundbars work best in smaller spaces like apartments or bedrooms, and they use tricky virtual sound techniques to give you a miniature surround sound experience.
Best Surround Sound for your Home Theatre
Onkyo, a trusted name in surround sound, offers this all-inclusive speaker system at a steal. It’s a 5.1 channel system, which means it comes with five speakers—front-left and -right, center, two surround—and a subwoofer. It also comes with a stereo receiver, so you don’t have to hunt down another compatible model.
The back panels of the equipment have clear labels on every connection. Combined with the moderate number of speakers, this makes setup a simpler task, so you can probably forgo professional installation.
We recommend this system because it’s a friendly gateway for new home theater buyers. Everything you need is included right in the box. There are certainly more sensitive—and expensive—speakers on the market, but if you’re just starting out in surround sound, we recommend you start here.
If you’re looking for something with a bit more power, check out our article on the best sound systems for your TV.
Best Soundbar for Your Bedroom
This sleek little guy is the perfect companion to a TV 42″ or larger, based on its 38″ length. It has a maximum decibel level of 100, which is about as loud as a jackhammer. And the deep bass modules do a pretty good job in smaller rooms, but it has a subwoofer output if you want a bit more oomph.
Some customers have complained about needing a separate remote to turn it on and off, but many newer TVs, especially those from VIZIO, can integrate with it so you need only the one remote.
Overall, this soundbar will be a great addition to the TV in your bedroom or small living room. It even comes with mounting hardware so you can hang it on the wall if you like. And with the low price, there’s really no excuse for you to keep using your TV’s tinny built-in speakers.
Because surround sound systems have so many speakers and wires, just getting everything connected can bring up issues. On top of that, it will take extra work to mount speakers and hide wires. If you’re not feeling confident about accomplishing all that work on your own, you’ll need to hire a professional.
On the other hand, soundbars have fewer wires. And rather than positioning multiple speakers around the room, you can just set a soundbar beneath your TV. If you’re a do-it-yourselfer, it’s a lot less hassle.
The Winner: Soundbars
You don’t need a very high a decibel level to fill a small room up with sound. Because of that, a soundbar with only a couple of built-in speakers is a good match for small living rooms or bedrooms.
But if your house has an enormous theater room, a soundbar just isn’t going to cut it. The bigger the room, the more powerful speakers you’ll need. If your place is especially big, you may also want to consider going with more speakers, like a 7.1 channel system (seven speakers and a subwoofer) rather than the standard 5.1 system.
A small room can still benefit from the great sound that comes from a surround sound system, but make sure the speakers aren’t so bulky that you’ll be tripping over them.
The Winner: Surround Sound
Stereo Imaging and Sweet Spots
Stereo imaging is used to refer to the immersive audio experience you get with surround sound, where the sound is coming from different directions and distances all around you. Dialogue usually comes from right in front of you, so it’s the easiest to hear—and background music stays in the background.
Some expensive soundbars can mimic this with multiple speakers set at different angles inside the bar. The sound bounces off walls and comes at you from different angles, but it’s not truly surround sound.
This also brings up the idea of “sweet spots.” A sweet spot is a place in your room where the audio sounds the best. With surround sound, you can adjust the direction your speakers face and get sweet spots wherever you want.
Soundbars aren’t so easy to manipulate—you’ll most likely get the best sound in front of the TV, at a specific distance from the screen that will vary by soundbar.
The Winner: Surround Sound
If you want to experience sound with more than just your ears, you’ll want to turn up the bass so you can feel the music. No surround sound system is truly complete without a subwoofer to bring the bass to life.
On the other hand, soundbars aren’t usually equipped with a subwoofer for bass. If bass is important to you, but you don’t want to go with surround sound, get a soundbar you can hook up to a separate subwoofer.
The Winner: Surround Sound
For a full audio experience, you’ll want to go with a surround sound system. But if you just want to experience some nicer audio than your TV’s built-in speakers can provide, pick up a soundbar and take your TV watching to the next level. You’ll be able to tell the difference right away.